Issues and challenges in conducting crossnational university at. A cross national comparative mixedmethods study involving 19 mental health wards in six service provider sites in england and wales. Simple random sampling was used to select the five representative kebeles. Simpson a, hannigan b, coffey m, jones a, barlow s, cohen r, et al. Prevalence of stunting and associated factors among preschool. Research methodology applied to a comparative case study of the deinstitutionalisation of children in bulgaria and ukraine chrissie gale abstract following the demise of the soviet union, world attention was alerted to the situation of. Potentials and limitations of comparative method in social. Responding to an interest among policymakers in comparative cross national information on health care, the organization for. Clearcut communication with patients, jefferson scale of empathy, and langer 14 items mindfulness scale. Mahler, 06491952, 97806491958, prentice hall, 2000. Recoveryfocused mental health care planning and co.
The paper seeks to provide guidance for those who have data from multiple countries and are considering writing a comparative or cross. Comparative research essentially compares two groups in an attempt to draw a conclusion about them. This paper is a report of a study to determine the transferability of the management of aggression and violence attitude scale to european mental health inpatient settings. A crossnational study on public confidence in police. Methodological dimensions and challenges in comparative analysis. The following section introduces some of these challenges and proposes solutions to overcome them. Comparative studies is committed to interdisciplinary and cross cultural inquiry and exchange. On the challenges of crossnational comparative media. Crossnational comparisons of health systems using oecd data, 1999. The management of aggression and violence attitude scale.
Cross sectional study design and data analysis chris olsen mathematics department george washington high school cedar rapids, iowa and diane marie m. The major aim of comparative research is to identify similarities and differences between social entities. Adapting kohns fourfold typology of models for comparative research, a range of epistemological debates regarding crossnational comparison are juxtaposed with the practical experiences of media and communications researchers in order to reveal the key research decisions and their consequences for substantive conclusions. In 1981 there were 106 residential burglaries per 1,000 households in the united states, compared with 41 per 1,000 households in england including wales. A comparative crossnational study of voter turnout and. Most such studies use quantitative methods, a few use. A crossnational comparative study of workfamily demands and resources article pdf available in international journal of cross cultural management 3. An institutional and crossnational approach, 2000, 383 pages, gregory s. How does culture shape students perceptions of scientists. The cross national study implies that one or more units in two or more societies. Lis acquires datasets with income, wealth, employment, and demographic data from many high and middleincome countries, harmonises them to enable cross national comparisons, and makes them publicly available in two databases, the luxembourg income study. There are no earlier cross national comparative studies analyzing the functions of the posture control mechanisms and its sensorymotor correlates in elderly subjects. Adewumi1, carolin funck1, van hoang nguyen1 and rie usui2.
Pdf on apr 1, 1984, ian masser and others published cross national comparative planning studies. They argue that cross national comparative research can. It is perhaps surprising therefore that there has todate been relatively little cross national comparative work within the field of ethnicity and health. There is a large body of cross national comparative research, including the cross national variation in public support for cuts in unemployment bene. To explain the factors responsible for cross national and cross cultural differences in bureaucratic behaviour. Research methodology applied to a comparative case study. The study included a survey of views on recovery, empowerment and therapeutic relationships in service users n448 and recovery in care.
However, we know little about the factors that can positively influence affective organizational commitment in a cross national context. Sociological association, 1987 presidential address melvin l. The world internet project has been intended to become the vehicle for tracking what happens as households and nations adopt and use the internet. The internet mediates social changes and social relations. The explanation for the canadian population health advantage has been attributed to differences. Postural balance and its sensorymotor correlates in 75. Lis is a cross national data center located in luxembourg which serves a global community of researchers, educators, and policy makers. Communication selfefficacy, empathy, and mindfulness were reported by questionnaires. To reach study participants, systematic sampling technique was utilized. Discussion about crossnational social research methods has centred on at least three. Kohn the johns hopkins university in this essay, i discuss some of the uses and dilemmas of cross national research. However, given the scale, complexity and cost of conducting any form of crossnational hpsr work, there remain relatively few such studies. My aim in discussing these is not to discourage potential cross national researchers but to highlight the need for a rigorous approach, if this type of. A crossnational comparative study of frames in the news claes h.
There are no earlier cross national comparative studies analyzing the functioning of the posture control mechanisms and its sensorymotor correlates in elderly subjects. A matrix of education as a new instrument juergen h. There is no distinct social science crossnational method. The cross national research group was established in 1985 with the aim of providing a forum for discussion and exchange of ideas and experience between researchers from different social science disciplines engaged in cross national comparative studies, for those planning to embark on cross national projects and for policymakers interested in exploiting the. While the link between organizational citizenship behavior ocb and organizational variables has been established, national cultures underlying this relationship and its influence remains poorly understood in school organizations. National comparative study on collaborative management of national parks ifeoluwa b. Spatially, crossnational comparisons are by far the most common, although. The criteria for assessing study quality and lucy gilson rigour must clearly be appropriate to the particular. Comparative research is a research methodology in the social sciences that aims to make.
Comparative research is persistent problems and promising. Pdf postural balance and its sensorymotor correlates in. Pdf a crossnational comparative study of workfamily. Recoveryfocused care planning and coordination in england. This paper addresses and discusses the central issues that researchers have to deal with when conducting crossnational comparative research within the area of egovernment. An institutional and cross national approach, 2000, 383 pages, gregory s.
The difficulty of measuring levels of relative corruption in different countries has presented a. Comparative research can be traced to a long history that has gained much attention in current research due to globalization, technological advances, etc. How to measure education in cross national comparison. In this study, i synthesize research that has used mixed methods for cross national comparison in order to identify current challenges and make recommendations. Keywords cross national comparative research, electoral participation, european union, media context, media system, pressparty parallelism in the study of political communication and its consequences, scholars have mainly stressed individuallevel media exposure effects on political attitudes and behavior. This conclusion is reinforced by the larger body of cross national comparative work, which has described, since the early 1980s, a sustained twoyear advantage in life expectancy for canada compared to the united states siddiqi and hertzman, 2007. A comparative analysis of technical and vocational education and training policy in selected african countries ezekiel bangalu arfo student no 212561884 submitted in fulfilment of the requirement for the degree of doctor of philosophy in the faculty of education university of kwazulunatal durban. Crossnational analysis pdf, 844kb world health organization. Researchers attempt to identify and analyze similarities and differences between groups, and these studies are most often cross national, comparing two separate people groups. Correspondence open access contributions and challenges of. This study includes more countries, more recent data, and a larger range of countrylevel explanatory variables than any existing cross national research on confidence in the police.
There is a large body of crossnational comparative research, including the crossnational variation in public support for cuts in unemployment bene. Discussion in this part starts by arguing the importance of. Understanding why employers discriminate, where and. The design of the gemm study is cross national, multigroup and factorial. When it comes to method, the majority agreement is that there is no methodology peculiar to comparative research. Some issues in crossnational comparative research methods. In addition to the research on the effect of electoral studies, there is research looking directly at other variables and their effect on voter turnout.
Yet, unlike other fields 14,15 public health researchers have not todate given considered attention to the opportunities and challenges that cross national comparative studies offer to the field of migration, ethnicity and health. My aim in discussing these is not to discourage potential cross national researchers but to highlight the need for a rigorous approach, if this type of research is to fulfil its promise. Theme papers cross national comparisons of the prevalences and correlates of mental disorders who international consortium in psychiatric epidemiology1 the international consortium in psychiatric epidemiology icpe was established in 1998 by who to carry out cross. We investigated whether there are differences in balance between elderly subjects living in different geographical areas, and analyzed the sensorymotor associates of balance.
This study compares patterns of gender difference in the receipt of informal care among communitydwelling older adults across the united s we use cookies to enhance your experience on our website. However, we know little about the factors that can positively influence affective organizational commitment in a cross. A crossnational study why is corruptionthe misuse of public office for private gain perceived to be more widespread in some countries than others. Their research and teaching focus on the rigorous comparative study of human experiences and ground our engagement with issues of social justice. Contributions and challenges of crossnational comparative. Cross national comparative mixedmethods case study of recoveryfocused mental health care planning and coordination. Additionally, hantrais and mangen 8 have discussed many advantages that can be obtained through cross national comparative research. Blais, massicotte, and yoshinka 2001 do a comparative study of election laws by comparing the laws governing the right to vote in 63 countries. While educational researchers often discuss the significance of ones culture in relation to children and education, culture has never previously been linked in terms of how children perceive scientists. Crossnational definition of crossnational by the free. A cross national comparative analysis of commercial television and online news providers annika sehl, richard fletcher, and robert g picard european journal of communication 0 10. Given the likely growth in such comparative research, we suggest that it is important to debate the value of. Lis acquires datasets with income, wealth, employment, and demographic data from many high and middleincome countries, harmonises them to enable cross national comparisons, and makes them publicly available in two databases, the luxembourg income study database lis and the luxembourg wealth study database lws.
A notable feature of the development of cross national research is the attention that is paid to methodological as well as theoretical issues. Characteristics of a comparative research design synonym. Pdf issues and strategies for conducting crossnational e. Comparative research, simply put, is the act of comparing two or more things with a view to discovering something about one or all of the things being compared. Apr 20, 2011 whether comparative education is a method or an area of content. This study applies a cross national comparative approach. Semetko this study of the main evening television news programs in four european countries focuses on the framing of news surrounding a major european event, the january 1. Crossnational comparative perspectives from the world. In summary, our study was informed by systems ideas. Comparative research seeks to compare and contrast nations, cultures, societies, and institutions. By continuing to use our website, you are agreeing to our use of cookies.
Cross national research as an analytic strategy american. Contextualization in crossnational comparative research taylor. The national systems of education and schooling are differently organized across national states and nations. Jun 29, 2011 contributions and challenges of cross national comparative research in migration, ethnicity and health. This included a survey using established standardised measures of service users n301 and staff n290 and embedded case studies involving interviews with staff, service users and carers n76. Linda hantrais holds a chair in the department of european studies. In contrast, case oriented comparative research often begins with an investigation of national differences, and, it has been argued, is better equipped to unpack causal complexity than variable. A comparative study of the importance of luxury value. A full account of our methods is provided elsewhere 28.
Theme papers crossnational comparisons of the prevalences. Contributions and challenges of cross national comparative research in migration, ethnicity and health. We conducted a cross national comparative study of recoveryfocused care planning and coordination in inpatient mental healthcare settings, employing a concurrent transformative mixed methods approach with embedded case studies 27. This included a survey using established standardised measures of service users n 301 and staff n 290 and embedded case studies involving interviews with staff, service users and carers n 76. A comparative analysis of technical and vocational.
Does gender matter in the receipt of informal care among. The management of aggression and violence attitude scale mavas. Researchers compare nations to broaden their views, build and test theories across settings, study transnational processes, assess the scope of beliefs, and learn from diverse policies. This study was addressed by a community based comparative cross sectional study design which was conducted among preschool children in albuko district from march to april 2017. Hence, cross national comparative research is rich in term of its capabilities to add different types of knowledge to the egovernment domain. Data was collected from final year student nurses in norway and sweden. Comparative studies students are encouraged to develop their critical and analytical skills and to become. Crossnational comparisons of health systems using oecd.
In the coverage of the launch of the euro, there was a greater emphasis on framing the news in terms of economic consequences. Recurrent interregional studies include comparing similar or different. At the same time, cross american journal of public health, 943. This technique often utilizes multiple disciplines in one study. Introduction the comparative measurement of education is a complex task. The study of the connection between the internet and society presents a window onto contemporary societies. Mindfulness predicts student nurses communication self. The findings are discussed in terms of influences on framing practices internal and external to journalism and the value of the cross national comparative approach. How to measure education in crossnational comparison. This paper addresses and discusses the central issues that researchers have to deal with when conducting cross national comparative research within the area of egovernment.
1295 626 1376 1431 1479 1505 1450 689 1076 273 1022 421 1468 555 393 122 691 551 961 456 976 467 1003 381 1380 729 716 1297 728 1035